Apple has filed more than 300 patents related to the technology
behind the iPhone.
LG Electronics claimed the iPhone's design was copied from
the LG Prada. Woo-Young Kwak, head of LG Mobile Handset R&D
Center, said at a press conference, “We consider that Apple
copied Prada phone after the design was unveiled when it was
presented in the iF Design Award and won the prize in September
2006.
On September 3, 1993, Infogear filed for the U.S. trademark
"I PHONE" and on March 20, 1996 applied for the trademark
"IPhone". "I Phone" was registered in March 1998, and "IPhone"
was registered in 1999. Since then, the I PHONE mark had been
abandoned. Infogear's trademarks cover "communications
terminals comprising computer hardware and software providing
integrated telephone, data communications and personal computer
functions" (1993 filing), and "computer hardware and software
for providing integrated telephone communication with
computerized global information networks" (1996 filing).
Infogear released a telephone with an integrated web browser
under the name iPhone in 1998. In 2000, Infogear won an
infringement claim against the owners of the iphones.com domain
name. In June 2000, Cisco Systems acquired Infogear, including
the iPhone trademark. On December 18, 2006 they released a
range of re-branded Voice over IP (VoIP) sets under the name
iPhone.
In October 2002, Apple applied for the "iPhone" trademark in
the United Kingdom, Australia, Singapore, and the European
Union. A Canadian application followed in October 2004 and a
New Zealand application in September 2006. As of October 2006
only the Singapore and Australian applications had been
granted. In September 2006, a company called Ocean Telecom
Services applied for an "iPhone" trademark in the United
States, United Kingdom and Hong Kong, following a filing in
Trinidad and Tobago. As the Ocean Telecom trademark
applications use exactly the same wording as Apple's New
Zealand application, it is assumed that Ocean Telecom is
applying on behalf of Apple. The Canadian application was
opposed in August 2005 by a Canadian company called Comwave who
themselves applied for the trademark three months later.
Comwave have been selling VoIP devices called iPhone since
2004.
Shortly after Steve Jobs' January 9, 2007 announcement that
Apple would be selling a product called iPhone in June 2007,
Cisco issued a statement that it had been negotiating trademark
licensing with Apple and expected Apple to agree to the final
documents that had been submitted the night before. On January
10, 2007 Cisco announced it had filed a lawsuit against Apple
over the infringement of the trademark iPhone, seeking an
injunction in federal court to prohibit Apple from using the
name. More recently, Cisco claimed that the trademark lawsuit
was a "minor skirmish" that was not about money, but about
interoperability.
On February 2, 2007, Apple and Cisco announced that they had
agreed to temporarily suspend litigation while they hold
settlement talks, and subsequently announced on February 20,
2007 that they had reached an agreement. Both companies will be
allowed to use the "iPhone" name in exchange for "exploring
interoperability" between their security, consumer, and
business communications products.
|